The interviewees
Prof. Dr Patrick Da-Cruz is Professor of Business Administration and Healthcare Management at the Faculty of Healthcare Management at Neu-Ulm University of Applied Sciences (HNU), as well as Academic Director of the MBA programme in Leadership and Management in Healthcare.
Prior to joining HNU, Mr Da-Cruz worked for leading strategy consultancies in the pharmaceutical and healthcare sectors, as well as holding senior management positions in healthcare organisations both in Germany and abroad.

Denise Marie Hradecky, LL.M., M.Sc., B.H., is an expert in healthcare, law and reform processes at Interorganizational, as well as a managing partner at Monvel UG. She advises national and international organisations on health policy and strategic issues and works as a lecturer. As the author of several specialist publications, she focuses in particular on transparency, governance and reform processes in the healthcare sector.

What does transparency in the healthcare sector actually mean to you? Why is this issue particularly relevant at the moment?
Denise Hradecky: Transparency in the healthcare sector is often equated with the mere publication of data. In my view, this understanding falls short. In my book *Transparency in the Healthcare Sector*, I describe transparency as a prerequisite for the ability to manage: A system can only be managed if relevant information is visible, comparable and understandable – in such a way that it can actually be taken into account in decision-making.
This is precisely where the key shortcoming currently lies. It is not a lack of data that is the problem, but rather its usability. Information is often fragmented, difficult to access and not presented in a way that provides guidance. This creates a paradoxical situation in which, despite high data availability, there is no real transparency.
The relevance of this issue is particularly evident at present, as the healthcare sector is under increasing pressure. Reform processes, a shortage of skilled staff and economic pressures are heightening the need to make well-informed decisions. In such a situation, a lack of transparency is not merely a structural problem, but a tangible risk. When decisions are made on the basis of insufficient or unorganised information, this leads to mismanagement – with direct consequences for care provision and the allocation of resources.
Where do you currently see the greatest need for action?
Denise Hradecky: In my view, the greatest need for action lies in ensuring that transparency is implemented consistently and across the board. It is not enough for some institutions to provide data whilst others do not. Transparency can only work if all hospitals are involved and information is collected and presented according to uniform standards.
If this is not the case, a structural problem arises: information asymmetries. Organisations that disclose data become comparable – those that do not evade this comparability. This does not lead to greater fairness; on the contrary, it can put smaller or less visible hospitals at a disadvantage.
At the same time, it must be recognised that implementing transparency requirements poses a challenge, particularly for smaller organisations. Setting up systems for data collection, processing and reporting ties up human and organisational resources that are not available to the same extent everywhere.
The real challenge, therefore, lies in designing transparency in such a way that, on the one hand, it is binding and comparable, whilst, on the other hand, it can be implemented in a practical manner. This means: clear standards, simple processes and, where necessary, targeted support for organisations that are unable to meet these requirements straight away.
Only under these conditions can transparency fulfil its true purpose – namely, to provide guidance without creating new inequalities.
How does greater transparency help patients in their day-to-day lives?
Denise Hradecky: When transparency is implemented consistently and effectively, it fundamentally changes the role of patients. They are no longer merely recipients of care, but become active decision-makers in their own care. Transparency enables them to better understand treatment options, recognise differences between healthcare providers and assess risks more realistically.
However, for this effect to actually materialise, one key prerequisite is crucial: information must be understandable. Transparency does not arise simply from the publication of data, but from its contextualisation and translation into a form that is accessible.
This is precisely where one of the biggest problems currently lies. Many existing resources are so complex that they are more off-putting than helpful. Rather than providing guidance, they often leave users feeling overwhelmed. Studies show that the use of such information depends heavily on whether it is understandable and whether users have the necessary skills to make sense of it.
Transparency that is not understood fails to serve its purpose. It does not provide guidance, but rather creates uncertainty – and is therefore ultimately ineffective.
What data should be consistently published to make decisions in the healthcare sector fairer and more transparent? In this context, how do you view the Bundesrat’s statement on the possible abolition of the Federal Hospital Atlas?
Denise Hradecky: The debate on transparency in the healthcare sector is often narrowed down too much to individual key figures. This creates the impression that publishing certain data automatically leads to better-quality decision-making. In my view, this falls short of the mark. Transparency only has an impact when it reveals the underlying connections – that is, when it becomes clear under what conditions certain outcomes arise and how stable they are.
It is therefore less about the isolated publication of individual indicators and more about a consistent understanding of healthcare provision. Decisions in the healthcare sector are complex because they are always caught between the conflicting demands of structure, processes and outcomes. If these levels are not linked together, transparency remains fragmented and, ultimately, of little help. What we need is a presentation that not only shows outcomes, but also explains how they arise and contextualises them.
Against this backdrop, I take a critical view of the debate surrounding the Federal Hospital Atlas. In my view, fundamentally questioning such tools distracts from the real problem. The problem is not the existence of transparency, but the way it is implemented. When data is presented in a way that is misleading, methodologically unclear or lacking in context, it creates uncertainty rather than trust. However, the consequence cannot be to roll back transparency.
Instead, the focus should be on developing transparency in a professional manner – with clear methodological standards, a transparent presentation and a consistent focus on users’ actual information needs. Transparency is not a static tool, but a learning system. It is precisely in this ongoing development that the real task lies.
On the debate surrounding the Federal Hospital Atlas, I would like to state quite clearly:
Abolishing it would send out the wrong signal. Yes, the tool is not yet perfect. But the answer to a lack of transparency cannot be to abolish it.
Other countries show that successful systems rely on centralised platforms, user-friendliness and trust. That is exactly where we need to be heading.
The right question is not: ‘Do we need the Atlas?’
But rather: ‘Why isn’t it good enough yet?’
What role do digital tools and AI play in presenting transparency in a way that is understandable and beneficial to all stakeholders?
Denise Hradecky: Digital tools and artificial intelligence are not merely a supplement, but a prerequisite for transparency in the healthcare sector to be feasible at all. Without digital support, it is virtually impossible to map out the complexity of the data, the multitude of stakeholders and the dynamics of care in a meaningful way. It is only through digital systems that it becomes possible to bring together information from different sources, analyse it and translate it into a form that is actually usable for different target groups.
At the same time, however, it would be a mistake to view transparency as primarily a technical issue. Technology can make information accessible, but it does not replace the structural prerequisites necessary for transparency to be effective in the first place. These include clear governance structures, effective incentive systems and, above all, trust in the handling of data. Without these foundations, even the best technological solution will remain ineffective.
This becomes particularly clear when dealing with AI. It has the potential to reveal complex interrelationships and support decision-making processes. At the same time, there is a risk that it will create new forms of opacity if the way it works cannot be understood. When decisions are based on algorithmic processes whose logic cannot be explained to those involved, the problem is merely shifted – from a lack of information to a lack of understanding.
That is why the real challenge lies not only in developing high-performance technologies, but also in integrating them responsibly. Digital transparency must be designed in such a way that it remains explainable, builds trust and is clearly regulated. Only then can it fulfil its purpose: to provide guidance and enable well-informed decisions.
Thank you very much for the interview!
The content and statements presented in the interviews reflect the interviewees’ perspectives and do not necessarily reflect the editorial team’s position.





